I'm having a hard time conveying my point. My point is, the rule regarding Mode C transponders is slightly absurd. There is no rule in real life stating that I must have my transponder on when I'm clear of the Mode C Veil.
In real life they also don't have a contactme feature to instruct hapless pilots who have no idea where they are to check in. However as pointed out there are rules beyond the Mode C veil, but clearly that's separate from desiring to simulate a thing like a Cub.
I'm honestly not bothered by non mode C or even non transponder if it were one out of many with one and I've had to deal with it occasionally due to apparent pilot error or some kind of bug in their client so its actually a necessary situation to be able to handle skill wise in my opinion. You can't just argue that reality lets you do this so on the network you should expect to be able to though. The CoC has no requirement to match reality exactly. I'd personally be happy if we had a provision put into the CoC that allows non ModeC/transponder operation as a controller consent thing just like emergencies. Until then though....